Skip to main content

Graduate Classical Mechanics · Variational principles, symmetries, and Noether quantities

Work in the vertical plane with downward y positive and g>0

Problem

Graduate Classical Mechanics practice problem

Work in the vertical plane with downward yy positive and g>0g>0. A particle starts from rest at the origin and slides without friction to the endpoint (πa,2a)(\pi a,2a) with a>0a>0. Do not replace the cycloid-versus-chord endpoint comparison by a magnetic momentum-map / gauge Noether identity, a central power-law effective-potential stability calculation, or an accelerating-frame canonical transform.

1. Using the Beltrami identity for the travel-time integrand
(which does not depend explicitly on the horizontal coordinate), derive the cycloidx=a(θ−sin⁡θ),y=a(1−cos⁡θ)x=a(\theta-\sin\theta),\qquad y=a(1-\cos\theta)as a stationary path, and prove the element identitiesds=2asin⁡(θ/2) dθ,v=2gy=2ag sin⁡(θ/2),dt=a/g dθ.ds=2a\sin(\theta/2)\,d\theta,\qquad v=\sqrt{2gy}=2\sqrt{ag}\,\sin(\theta/2),\qquad dt=\sqrt{a/g}\,d\theta.2. Specialize to the endpoint θ1=π\theta_1=\pi, which is the point
(πa,2a)(\pi a,2a). Prove that the cycloid transit time isTcycloid=πa/g.T_{\mathrm{cycloid}}=\pi\sqrt{a/g}.3. For the straight constant-slope chord from the origin to
(πa,2a)(\pi a,2a), prove that the transit time from rest isTchord=π2+4 a/gT_{\mathrm{chord}}=\sqrt{\pi^2+4}\,\sqrt{a/g}and that Tchord>TcycloidT_{\mathrm{chord}}>T_{\mathrm{cycloid}}. At the sample a=g=1a=g=1, report the numerical pairTcycloid=π,Tchord=π2+4.T_{\mathrm{cycloid}}=\pi,\qquad T_{\mathrm{chord}}=\sqrt{\pi^2+4}.4. Audit both sentences: (i) “the cycloid transit is a full 2π2\pi
generating period, so Tcycloid=2πa/gT_{\mathrm{cycloid}}=2\pi\sqrt{a/g} rather than πa/g\pi\sqrt{a/g}”; (ii) “the chord time is (π2+4)1/4a/g(\pi^2+4)^{1/4}\sqrt{a/g}, so at a=g=1a=g=1 one does not obtain π2+4\sqrt{\pi^2+4}.” Scope is the Beltrami derivation and this endpoint comparison only; do not claim global uniqueness over nonsmooth curves.

Hint

Hint

Write T[y]=∫0x11+y′2/2gy dxT[y]=\int_0^{x_1}\sqrt{1+y'^2}/\sqrt{2gy}\,dx and apply Beltrami. The first integral rearranges to y(1+y′2)=y(1+y'^2)= constant, which is solved by the stated cycloid.

Check your work

Work the problem yourself first. Then open it in Training to check your answer and read the full worked solution.

Create a free account to check your answer and see the solution. Create a free account.

More Graduate Classical Mechanics practice problems