Skip to main content

Mathematical Statistics II · Bootstrap, permutation, and simulation-based inference

The sample is x=(1,2,4) with n=3

Problem

The sample is $x=(1,2,4)$ with $n=3$. The functional of interest is the squared sample mean \[ \hat\theta=\bar x^2. \] Write $\hat\theta_{(i)}$ for the same functional computed after deleting the $i$th observation, and write $\bar\theta_{(\cdot)}=n^{-1}\sum_i\hat\theta_{(i)}$ for the leave-one-out mean. 1. Prove $\bar x=7/3$ and $\hat\theta=49/9$. Compute the three leave-one-out values \[ \hat\theta_{(1)}=9,\qquad \hat\theta_{(2)}=\frac{25}{4},\qquad \hat\theta_{(3)}=\frac94, \] and their mean $\bar\theta_{(\cdot)}=35/6$. 2. The jackknife bias estimate is $(n-1)\bigl(\bar\theta_{(\cdot)}-\hat\theta\bigr)$. Prove that this equals $7/9$, and that the bias-corrected estimator $\hat\theta-\widehat{\mathrm{bias}}$ equals $14/3$. 3. The pseudovalues are $\tilde\theta_i=n\hat\theta-(n-1)\hat\theta_{(i)}$. Prove \[ \bigl(\tilde\theta_1,\tilde\theta_2,\tilde\theta_3\bigr) =\Bigl(-\frac53,\frac{23}{6},\frac{71}{6}\Bigr) \] and that their average is again $14/3$. The jackknife variance is \[ \widehat V =\frac{n-1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^n \bigl(\hat\theta_{(i)}-\bar\theta_{(\cdot)}\bigr)^2 =\frac{1}{n(n-1)} \sum_{i=1}^n\bigl(\tilde\theta_i-\bar{\tilde\theta}\bigr)^2. \] Prove $\widehat V=553/36$. 4. Audit both sentences: (i) “the bias factor is $n$ rather than $n-1$, or the functional is the unsquared mean, giving bias $7/18$ or $0$”; (ii) “the variance uses $(n-1)/n$ times the sum of *pseudovalue* squared deviations, giving $553/9$, or this is a nonparametric bootstrap of the sample maximum.” Stay inside the delete-one jackknife of $\bar x^2$. Do not replace the functional by $\bar x$ or by a bootstrap of the maximum.

Hint

$\bar x=7/3$ and $\hat\theta=49/9$. The three leave-one-out means are $3$, $5/2$, and $3/2$.

Check your work

Work the problem yourself first. Then open it in Training to check your answer and read the full worked solution.

The answer check and full solution for this problem come with ProofAnvil Practice membership ($19 USD monthly). See membership. Or start with the free Mathematical Statistics II sample problem: Try the free sample problem.

More Mathematical Statistics II practice problems