Thermodynamics · Microscopic interpretation and ensembles bridge
Two Einstein solids exchange four quanta with multiplicity-weighted probabilities
Problem
Two weakly coupled Einstein solids, $A$ and $B$, form an isolated composite system. Solid $A$ has $N_A=2$ distinguishable oscillators, solid $B$ has $N_B=3$, and the composite contains exactly $q_{\mathrm{tot}}=4$ indistinguishable energy quanta. The oscillator frequencies are equal, so specifying $q_A$ fixes $q_B=4-q_A$. In the Einstein-solid model, \[ \Omega(N,q)=\binom{q+N-1}{q}. \] Assume every accessible composite microstate is equally likely. 1. For each $q_A=0,1,2,3,4$, compute \[ w(q_A)=\Omega(N_A,q_A)\Omega(N_B,4-q_A). \] Give the five weights in increasing order of $q_A$ and sum them. 2. Normalize the weights to obtain $P(q_A)$. Identify the most probable macrostate and its probability. 3. Compute the exact expectation $\langle q_A\rangle$. Explain why it need not equal the modal allocation. 4. Check the total multiplicity independently by treating all five oscillators as one Einstein solid. State why multiplicities multiply for a specified split but add when mutually exclusive splits are combined. 5. State the assumptions supporting the probability model. Do not replace this microcanonical counting calculation with canonical partition-function derivatives or with the checked-in two-level fluctuation exercise.
Hint
For $N_A=2$, $\Omega_A(q_A)=q_A+1$. For $N_B=3$, use $\Omega_B(q_B)=\binom{q_B+2}{2}$.
Check your work
Work the problem yourself first. Then open it in Training to check your answer and read the full worked solution.
The answer check and full solution for this problem come with ProofAnvil Practice membership ($19 USD monthly). See membership. Or start with the free Thermodynamics sample problem: Try the free sample problem.
More Thermodynamics practice problems
- A sealed, rigid 0.080 m³ pharmaceutical autoclave is loaded with a spatially uniform…Equilibrium states, work, heat, and the first law
- A closed-system gas is taken through a quasi-equilibrium polytropic process of the form…Equilibrium states, work, heat, and the first law
- A rigid tank contains 0.80 kg of argon at 350 kPa and 120 °C (393 K)Entropy and the second law
- Wet steam at 0.60 MPa with quality x_1 = 0.950 is throttled steadily through an…Entropy and the second law
- Two reversible Carnot heat engines operate in seriesThermodynamic potentials and Legendre transforms
- Refrigerant-134a is compressed in a steadily operating adiabatic compressor of a…Response functions and stability
- Osmotic pressure from the solvent chemical potentialThermodynamic potentials and Legendre transforms
- A virial gas changes its Joule-Thomson sign at twice the characteristic temperatureResponse functions and stability
- The binary lever rule is a component balance across a tie linePhase equilibrium and transitions